With Watchmen mania continuing to grow, I was curious if one aspect of it was going to make it to the big screen. Namely, the infamous "Tales of the Black Freighter" comic book within a comic book. While it appears that it will not, it will at least be making it to the small screen!
Watchmen: Tales of the Black Freighter & Under the Hood
But just don't listen to me blab about it. Check out the trailer yourself!
In Part I, I examined some of the issues I saw with rituals in 4th Edition D&D. Since then, Jonathan at The Core Mechanic came up with some interesting alternative rules that address many of the issues I spoke about. It is definitely worth a read.
Nevertheless, I feel the need to present my own set of house rules on rituals. I take a somewhat different direction than Jonathan, and I am curious to find out what people think about them.
You are able to master and perform rituals of your level or lower. Unlike the Ritual Caster feat, you are not limited in the number of rituals you can master. See PHB Chapter 10 for more information on how to perform rituals.
Prerequisite: Trained in Arcana or Religion
Benefit: You can master and perform four rituals of your level or lower. You gain one ritual for free when the feat is first acquired. The remaining three must be mastered normally (see Chapter 10). Once you have mastered four rituals, you cannot master any more. However, you can change which rituals you know through retraining. When you retrain a ritual, it is removed from your ritual book and replaced with the new one. See Chapter 10 for more information on how to perform rituals. This feat can be taken multiple times. Each time it is taken, you are able to master and perform four additional rituals.
Performing a ritual is very draining. The number of rituals you can perform per day depends on your level:
At 1st - 10th level, you can perform two rituals per day.
At 11th - 20th level, you can perform four rituals per day.
At 21st - 30th level, you can perform six rituals per day.
Each time you reach a milestone (see page 259), you regain the ability to perform one ritual if you have already expended that ability.
After you take an extended rest, your ability to perform rituals is renewed and you start fresh with regard to the number of rituals you can perform per day.
Please note that there are no limits to the ability to assist with a ritual, or to the ability to utilize ritual scrolls.
When using the rules above, it is recommended that both the purchase price and the component costs of rituals be cut in half.
I majored in English Literature in college. Considering I work with computers for a living, that usually surprises people. Nevertheless, I remain a voracious reader, devouring an eclectic mix of genres, including everything from literary classics to comic books to science fiction & fantasy.
Self-described as "The Classic Regency Romance - Now with Ultraviolent Zombie Mayhem!", author Seth Grahame-Smith
I wish him the best of luck. Pride and Prejudice
on my Amazon Wishlist? You decide! A friend of mine often bemoans the lack of options available to wizards in 4th Edition Dungeons & Dragons. He feels with the focus on combat spellcasting eliminated most of the non-combat "game changing" effects old-school Wizards were able to perform. I can definitely see his point. However, from my experience many people looking at Wizards in 4th Edition tend to overlook the importance of rituals.
Rituals are where you can still find the types of spells that were common in previous editions of the game. Rituals are not combat focused. They often have long lasting effects. Certain categories of old school spells, like divinations, have moved entirely over to this category.
Because of this, I have found that judicious use of rituals can inject a bit of the feel of the old editions of D&D into 4th Edition. When I first converted my Divine Oracle Issac Winter from 3rd Edition to 4th Edition, I worried quite a bit that the character would be unrecognizable. While the old Issac was effective in combat, he really shined outside of it. Issac was infamous for using divinations to prepare the party and confound his enemies. While I won't deny that he is a bit more limited in this regard, a heavy focus on divination, exploration, restoration, and scrying rituals really help make him feel like the Issac of old.
That being said, I have several issues with rituals as they are written. In many ways I feel they are almost an afterthought, existing merely to bridge the 3rd Edition and 4th edition. Sadly, the embody some of the worst issues of that edition as well.
One problem with rituals is that the primary limitation on how many rituals you can posses or perform is financial. Either you have the money to purchase new rituals and components or you don't. While I like the feel of components being an important part of the game again, how much gold flows through a campaign can vary wildly depending on the DM and the nature of the game.
Oddly, this is a design problem that the game designers at Wizards of the Coast already saw and addressed in another aspect of the game: When the 3rd Edition Magic Item Compendium was discussed on the D&D Podcast, the concept that magic items were limited only by price was seen as an issue. Since game designers can be a bit conservative at times, they tended to set prices high, often to the point where no sane character would ever buy them. I already see this problem cropping up in some rituals.
Another issue is the Ritual Caster Feat. I actually like the fact that the feat is open to any character trained in Arcana or Religion. Characters like the Grey Mouser or Giles from Buffy the Vampire Slayer were portrayed as able to cast elaborate spells with time and copious amounts of study, but never as true wizards or witches.
So why do I see it as an issue? Well, mostly because rituals have what I call "the polymorph issue". The spell Polymorph was infamous in 3rd Edition because a single spell allowed you to transform into almost any creature in the Monster Manual, limited by hit dice. It was a case of one spell providing to many options to the player. To make things worse, since almost every book produced had more monsters in it, the spell became better with every book.
The Ritual Caster feat has a similar issue. For the cost of one feat, the whole world of rituals opens up to the character. Also, like Polymorph, the number of options available to a Ritual Caster increases with almost every book Wizards of the Coast puts out.
Still, I think that eliminating rituals from the game would be a case of throwing the baby out with the bath water. Rituals really add a lot of flavor to D&D 4th Edition. They also fill an important niche in the 4th Edition ecosystem, namely that they are the only mechanism for casting magic outside of the rigid structure of powers.
Rituals just need a little attention, and perhaps a little more "crunch" to make them a truly useful and viable part of 4th Edition. That is where Part II will come in. I am currently putting together a number of house rules for rituals which I feel will solve at least some of these issues without eliminating the flavor that makes them so appealing in the first place.
I have a confession to make. I have been enjoying Star Wars: The Clone Wars. It may not be high art, but it reminds me of the kind of stories you would see in a Star Wars game brought to the small screen. At least that is what it does for me normally. However, I felt that Trespass, the most recent episode, was not very good. FYI... my commentary below has a ton of spoilers, so don't read it if you haven't watched the episode yet.
The story starts simply enough. For reasons never fully explained the Republic placed a Clone Trooper base on an uninhabited ice planet. They lose contact with this base, so they decide to send a group consisting of Anakin Skywalker, Obi-Wan Kenobi, C-3P0, R2-D2, a bunch of Storm Clone Troopers, and two politicians from a nearby planet, who I will call Chairman Homicidal and Senator Jailbait.
They arrive at the base to find it deserted, with the exception of Clone Trooper helmets on spears. Chairman homicidal immediately decides it must be the work of those wacky Separatists. Were the spears the tip off? In any case, they travel to the nearby Seperatist base, who apparently also love uninhabited ice planets, only to find the head of droids on pikes as well.
Eventually, it is discovered that the stone cold killers known as the Talz are responsible. Apparently trained Storm Clone Troopers and Battle Droids are no match for primitive aliens chucking flint tipped spears. Although, to be fair, decades later Storm Troopers fair no better against Ewoks.
Obi-Wan and Anakin go to speak with the Talz, and eventually receive their demands. Well, one demand actually: "Leave or we kill you". When this is reported back to Chairman Homicidal, he immediately decides to commit genocide.
Fortunately, Chairman Homicidal is pretty ineffective at wiping out the primitive Talz. Taking some Storm Clone Troopers out on military speeders, the kind with shields and blaster cannons, they manage to get ambushed. They then stop the bikes and engage the spear-wielding Talz with their blaster pistols. Unfortunately for them, the Talz spears cut through Storm Clone Trooper armor like a knife through butter and Chairman Homicidal is fatally wounded.
Obi-Wan urges Senator Jailbait to make peace with the Talz, which is all she has wanted to do all along. She then concedes to the Talz demands to leave the planet forever, and Obi-Wan praises her skill as a negotiator. The End.
I know Star Wars often has plot holes you can drive a truck through, but it was seriously bad this episode. The ice planet is a complete MacGuffin, and a bad one at that. Everyone is fighting over the planet, but there seem to be no consequences for leaving it. Similarly, Chairman Homicidal's evilness and Senator Jailbait's innocence are comically overdone.
Oh well. Hopefully the next episode will be better.
The D&D Insider Character Builder has arrived... and it's not bad. Once I downloaded the full version, I figured a good test of the program would be to enter in Issac Winter, one of my Lord's of Tyr characters. Issac is a 16th level Divine Oracle, so I figured he would be a decent test of how the Character Builder handles a mid-Paragon level character being entered from scratch.
The answer turned out to be "surprisingly well". After launching the Character Builder and choosing to create a new character, I immediately clicked over to the Level Up tab. I entered in 71213 and clicked SET XP. I then jumped back to the start of the character creation process, half-expecting the whole thing to be mucked up.
Instead the character creation process proceeded flawlessly. Choosing abilities was simple and intuitive, even though I had a number of advances to take because of my level. Choosing my powers was similarly intuitive, although I had to take certain first level powers only to immediately discard them. Still, the ease of character creation was astounding, especially considering the level of the character.
Another nice touch is that you can unlock the panels of the character sheet. This allows you to rearrange the data contained on the sheet to fit your tastes. I can see this being very useful for certain characters or for picky players.
Now, this is not to say that the Character Builder is perfect. At the moment, it doesn't support containers. So Issac still shows "heavily encumbered" despite his Heward's Handy Haversack. Also, support for house rules is limited at this point. You can add names and information, but nothing that auto-calculates.
I should note that according to the Character Builder forums, support for containers and for house rules that affect the auto-calculating sheet are coming. Still, it does highlight a concern of mine. I am used to working with the open source PCGen, which I still use to maintain my 3.5 Characters. PCGen was designed with flexibility in mind. Its open source nature made it relatively easy to hack into the data sets and change anything you wanted. What PCGen sacrificed for this was ease of use (although it did improve over time).
Nevertheless, I am impressed with the Character Builder. I have to admit, I have been somewhat skeptical of the value of D&D Insider so far. The fact that the Character Builder is a useful and usable tool helps restore my trust. I remain hopeful that the Character Builder, as well as the rest of D&D Insider, will continue to improve over time.
It has been awhile since I reviewed any comic books on my blog. So I figure what better way to be relevant than to review a comic first published in 1987?
Despite this, I never sought out Scott McCloud's earlier works. I am not sure why. It might be that I was sure I was going to be disappointed in it. I held his scholarly works on the subject of comics in such high regard that I was afraid of finding out that the emperor had no clothes after all. It helped that his books were long out of print and hard to find.
When the black and white issues of Zot! (1987-1991) were compiled on one easy to find trade paperback, I figured I finally had run out of excuses.
I shouldn't have worried. The stories focus on Zot, a young Flash Gordon style adventurer from an alternate universe set in the "retro-future" of 1965, and Jenny, a typical teenage girl from our world. Technology from Zot's world allows the characters to travel between the two dimensions. The comics are a mixture between the high adventure in Zot's world and the smaller, more personal stories on Jenny's.
This premise sounds pretty typical for a superhero comic. What makes it special is the care with which Scott develops his themes. Jenny is not a true pessimist, but she has to deal with all of the little disappointments of living in the our world. Seeing Zot's "perfect" world throws these problems into sharp contrast. On the other hand, Zot can't help but see the best in both worlds. It's not that Zot doesn't see the bad, it's just that he believes it is outweighed by the good.
In short, Zot is a character driven book, but it is a book about little changes, rather than big ones. The action sequences are mostly superfluous, except in how they affect the characters emotionally. It's hard for me to think of another book like it. The best I can come up with is Marvels
I guess I would just recommend that you check it out yourself!
